- Former England coach on the week that proved the experiment has failed… it is merely not producing a good contest for gamers or leisure for followers
- Subscribe to Mail+ to learn the very best cricket protection all through the home and worldwide season – for simply £1.99 a month plus 80% fewer adverts
The final two rounds of County Championship fixtures had been the newest to be performed utilizing a Kookaburra ball, relatively than the standard Dukes, as a part of an ongoing experiment following a evaluation into English cricket led by former England captain Sir Andrew Strauss three years in the past.
The thought is that the ball – utilized in nearly all abroad nations, and regarded to lose its form faster and go softer earlier – will give English bowlers expertise of bowling in unfamiliar situations and enhance their skillset.
However over the past fortnight we’ve seen bowlers toil, batters making hay with 59 centuries scored, Surrey piling on the best complete in 18 years of Championship cricket and 13 of the 18 matches ending in attracts.
In principle, utilizing a Kookaburra ball is a worthy experiment as a result of in case you go and play Take a look at cricket, that’s what you may be utilizing abroad however we’ve seen sufficient now to know that it doesn’t match our situations.
This week, I’ve seen two separate Championship video games with gradual and low pitches at Chesterfield and York.
After the primary 15 overs, the ball has gone smooth, the pitch is unreceptive, and you may see the ball hitting the underside of the bat nearly each time. The plunk seems like a railway sleeper.
Dom Sibley of Surrey hit a triple century in his aspect’s draw towards Durham this week
The groups shook fingers on a boring draw on day 4 with Durham 262-0 of their second innings
Surrey scoring 820 and declaring towards Durham appeared like a protest towards the Kookaburra. And let’s be sincere. It is turning right into a farce.
We’ve had 800s, 700s, 600s and 500s and it’s as a result of the ball is just not suited to the UK. Seven of the 9 matches resulted in attracts final week and one other six this week. The chance of a result’s minimal.
Simply ask the query innocently to the bowlers and stand by for some actual expletives.
Like I stated, the thought is affordable however pitches in Australia are by and enormous, more durable, faster and bouncier. And the local weather of Australia is by and enormous, scorching.
For it to work and groups to get 20 wickets, you want massive tempo, a tough, fast pitch, sunshine and high quality wrist spin. All of those are commodities that we don’t get in abundance right here.
There’s no tempo off the pitch, no tempo off the ball and hardly any wrist spin, so the batters usually are not scoring that shortly however you possibly can’t get them out.
Gamers like Shane Warne had been high-quality with that as a result of they’d spin something. Give him any ball and he’d say ‘I’m not bothered what you give me, I will spin it’. However he’s considered one of a form.
Talking to my mates at York, they stated the primary two days of Yorkshire’s match with Essex had been boring. No one desires to observe that and the response throughout social media tells you all the things as a result of it isn’t an excellent contest.
Northamptonshire’s Calvin Harrison hit considered one of 4 centuries within the first innings towards Kent
Sir Andrew Strauss pushed for using the Kookaburra ball in county cricket
Return to somebody like Michael Atherton, who whilst a gap batter, would all the time need an excellent contest between bat and ball. With the Kookaburra ball right here, it’s fully loaded in the direction of the batter.
It’s a significantly better thought for these bowlers that England see as potential Take a look at cricketers to play correct cricket overseas, maybe by means of a Lions tour.
It’s additionally value mentioning that pitches in Australia are abrasive so when the ball will get softer, reverse swing is available in. We not often get that right here. My conclusion is that there’s no worth within the experiment.
And why are we obsessive about the Kookaburra ball over right here? I do know the Aussies have trialled utilizing a Dukes ball earlier than however they don’t hassle anymore.
Finally, this trial is coming on the compromise of the standard of our county cricket. And I don’t like the thought of experimenting with our conventional product. It’s a cloth of society.
And no, I’m not having a phrase with my mate Rob Key as a result of he’s behind it!
